Muscle memory: why PTs make you do the same strength movements on repeat

black woman showing arm muscles

Credit: Getty

Strong Women


Muscle memory: why PTs make you do the same strength movements on repeat

By Jessica Harris

2 years ago

7 min read

Being made to the same old moves again and again may be boring but there’s a reason PTs and instructors get us to repeat curls and lifts, writes Jessica Harris.


There’s nothing more frustrating than training hard for months… only to get sick, injured or too busy to workout. Perhaps you’ve sprained your ankle or your new job is sucking all your exercise motivation. Days turn into weeks and before you know it, you’ve not worked out for months. 

When that happens, it can be easy to get despondent. You convince yourself that you’re much less fit than you used to be and that perhaps there’s no point in working back to where you used to be. But that’s just not true. 

Your body is designed to help you move with ease, whether that’s a few days after a hard run or a month after your last gym session. How? Well, it’s all to do with muscle memory – the mechanism that allows you to resume your muscle-building activities near enough where you left off. Here’s how that muscle memory process works.

What is muscle memory?

The term ‘muscle memory’ is a bit of a red herring. “Muscles don’t actually have a capacity for true memory,” confirms Nicola Phillips, professor of physiotherapy at Cardiff University. “When we learn a new skill, we usually have to repeat it a number of times and concentrate on doing it. The more that happens, the more  we refine that movement until we don’t have to consciously think about it any more — the movement has become ‘automatic’. This is what people call ‘muscle memory’. 

Studies have shown that when you learn a new skill, you use lots of different areas of your brain, “such as the pre-motor cortex (for planning movement) and basal ganglia (for initiating movement and filtering information). As long as the environment stays the same, we can do this quite automatically which is why it is called muscle memory.”

Although it can sometimes feel like a long, hard slog to reach your fitness goals, every rep and set is actually laying groundwork that your future self will be thankful for. “When you lift weights, the cells in your muscles and their nuclei split and then grow,” explains personal trainer Penny Weston

woman lifting dumbbells

Credit: Getty

“The heavier the weights and the resistance, the more they’ll multiply, which is why your muscle mass increases. However, if you stop training for a period of time, the nuclei stop splitting and don’t grow any bigger.” They might even shrink a little but they don’t completely disappear, which is why when you resume training, our body remembers how to grow muscle mass again.

Why you need to repeat exercises again and again to build muscle

Weston explains: “Through repeating a movement again and again, such as lifting a weight, you’re committing that specific motor task into memory. The muscles are full of neurons; these are attached to the nervous system and are part of this motor learning.”

The part of the brain that’s responsible for movement develops stronger connections between these motion neurons, and these connections make the memory better and more easily accessible.  

The point here is that strength training can be tedious; it involves lots of the same movements over a number of reps. That serves a double purpose: it allows for hypertrophy (the process that gets you stronger), and builds your muscle memory. So, next time you feel bored during a long pyramid set, know that you’re laying those insurance foundations should you need a break at any time.

Muscle memory-boosting workout

Why not give the below exercises a go to get that muscle memory pumping? Try three sets of 12 reps of each, and aim to do them twice a week for the next month or so. 

Single overhead press

  1. Stand feet hip-width apart, holding a dumbbell in your right hand
  2. Bring the dumbbell up to shoulder height before pushing up above your head. Extend your free arm for better balance
  3. Slowly return to shoulder height
  4. Repeat and then switch to the other side

Goblet squat

  1. Start off standing with feet hip-width apart
  2. If using a kettlebell, turn it so that you’re holding the bell and the handle is facing the floor. If using a dumbbell, hold onto one end, thumbs crossed for support
  3. To squat, bend at the knees and sit back as if going to sit in a chair
  4. Once you’ve gone as low as you can without moving your feet or bringing your knees over your toes, come back up by squeezing your glutes

Deadlift

  1. Stand with your feet hip-width apart.
  2. Bend your knees to grab your dumbells, barbell or kettlebells, which should be placed either side of your feet.
  3. Lift up as you straighten your knees and back, bringing the dumbells up with you until your arms are also straight.
  4. Return the dumbells back down to the ground, bending your knees as you go.

Jump lunge

  1. Start by standing with your right leg forward and your left leg back
  2. Bend your knees and lower yourself into a lunge, keeping your core tight
  3. Then push up through your feet and jump upwards, switching your feet so that when your left leg is in front and your right lack is back
  4. Land carefully with bent knees, so that your left knee is on top of the left foot
  5. Switch

How long does muscle memory last?

Weston concludes that “while your muscles themselves don’t actually ‘remember’ things, they’re full of neurons attached to your nervous system that do.” As easy as it would be to sit back and rely on our muscle memory to see us through times of fatigue or plateau, Weston is quick to point out that like all good things, you’ve got to put the work in first. 

The mere thought of picking up a dumbbell or slipping on those trainers can feel like a mammoth undertaking after an exercise hiatus, but Weston assures us that getting back into the swing of things will be easier than you think. The only snag is that there’s a window of time in which to resume training; once that’s past, things get infinitely more difficult.

“When you start working out again after a period of rest or inactivity, the brain remembers the connections between neurons and the motor cortex and the muscles acclimatise quicker to the workout. They’ll build in strength and size faster and more easily than they would have done if you had never worked out before,” she explains. 

While there’s no definitive answer as to how long we can stop exercising for before muscle memory begins to fade, Weston says that she’s read it can last for up to 15 years, while others claim it lasts a matter of months. Perhaps it really just depends on how fit and experienced you were before the break.

How easy exercise is after a break depends on how fit you were before

Muscle memory and injury recovery

There’s always an exception to the rule and in this case, it’s injury. Rest and rehab is required before jumping back onto the saddle, but if you’re relying on muscle memory to pick up where you left off, it could be a lengthier recovery. “After a break, as long as you build up gradually, your muscles will adapt quicker and the relative effort and concentration needed will reduce much quicker than when you first learned,” Professor Phillips explains.

“However, if the break is from an injury, you may also need to think about what has changed in the muscle (like having more scar tissue for example). The brain will then need to re-learn the skilled movement with that slightly different information coming into the central nervous system than before the injury.” 

That may sound tedious but Phillips does go onto say that once you start using similar strategies to how you learned the task in the first place, the coordinated movement usually returns in its adapted format quicker than the original learning.

That re-learning process is absolutely crucial for building back stronger. Skip straight to muscle strengthening and you risk elongating your recovery. “That often results in apparently slower reactions, as the muscle can produce the force but it can’t act quick enough,” Phillips says. “It’s why you sometimes feel a bit sluggish when you first go back to your sport and perhaps miss a tackle in football or don’t quite get your racquet to the ball in tennis.”


Ease yourself back into fitness with one of our 15-minute mobility videos

Images: Getty

Share this article

Login To Favourite

A weekly dose of expert-backed tips on everything from gut health to running.

By signing up you agree to occasionally receive offers and promotions from Stylist. Newsletters may contain online ads and content funded by carefully selected partners. Don’t worry, we’ll never share or sell your data. You can opt-out at any time. For more information read Stylist’s Privacy Policy

Thank you!

You’re now subscribed to all our newsletters. You can manage your subscriptions at any time from an email or from a MyStylist account.