Beauty Pie: the 8 beauty editor-approved products to buy first

Best beauty pie products

Credit: Beauty Pie

Stylist Loves


Beauty Pie: the 8 beauty editor-approved products to buy first

By Lucy Partington

3 years ago

1 min read

The best Beauty Pie bits to treat yourself to immediately, according to a beauty editor. 

If you haven’t heard of Beauty Pie, where have you been? The members-only club was the first of its kind when it launched in 2017 – and it’s still unrivalled today. 

The premise is pretty simple: every month you pay a subscription fee that gives you access to luxury products at factory prices. The products are all selected and tested by founder Marcia Kilgore (who’s also the brains behind brands like Soap & Glory, Bliss Spa and FitFlop), and made at factories around the world that are also handpicked by Kilgore.

Beauty Pie cuts out the middleman, and by stripping out the markup prices typically applied to beauty products (which the brand says can be up to 10 times the finished manufacturing costs), it can pass those savings onto members. It sounds too good to be true, but it’s really not: the products, all of which have incredible reviews, are truly brilliant. 

But with so much choice, it’s hard to know what to buy first. Below, contributing beauty editor Lucy Partington chooses her favourite bits that are worth adding to your basket.

The Beauty Pie products you should buy first

BEAUTYPIE_Plantastic_Apricot_Butter_Cleansing_Balm_968500_2000_1

Plantastic Apricot Butter Cleansing Balm

I’d suggest making this the very first product you buy – it’s the most perfect balm cleanser that melts away even the hardiest of waterproof mascara. It doesn’t leave any sort of film or greasy residue, and instead leaves skin feeling nourished and ready for a second cleanse. 

Shop Plantastic Apricot Butter Cleansing Balm at Beauty Pie, £19.50 (£50 for non-members)

buy now

BEAUTYPIE_Wondercolour_Nail_Polish_Le_Milk_968050_2000_1

Wondercolour Nail Polish in Le Milk

You know sometimes when you just want your nails to look healthy and shiny? That’s exactly what this polish does. It’s a super pale, barely-there shade of pink that can be built up if you want it to be more opaque, and I usually get a good week’s wear without chipping.

Shop Wondercolour Nail Polish in Le Milk at Beauty Pie, £7 (£15 for non-members)

buy now

Beauty Pie Clean House Luxury Scented Candle

Clean House Luxury Scented Candle

Every time I light this candle I get compliments, it really is the smell of freshly washed bedding and I’m obsessed with it. It burns nice and evenly (very important!) and the scent lingers more impressively than some of its high-end counterparts.

Shop Clean House Luxury Scented Candle at Beauty Pie, £20 (£60 for non-members)

buy now

beauty pie Triple Beauty Luminizing Wand

Triple Beauty Luminizing Wand

I never get more compliments on my highlighter than when I wear this: the perfect shade of champagne, it illuminates skin without being glittery and sheens perfectly in the light. Plus, my tube has lasted me longer I should probably admit – a must-have.

Shop Triple Beauty Luminizing Wand at Beauty Pie, £9 (£25 for non-members)

buy now

Beauty Pie Superdose C C-Suite Rapid Action Power Brightener

Superdose C C-Suite Rapid Action Power Brightener

If you want a vitamin C serum that’s lightweight and not oily, look no further. One of my all-time favourite antioxidants, it’s not sticky or greasy – instead, it absorbs into skin like a dream and layers perfectly underneath sunscreen to create the easiest morning routine in existence. 

Shop Superdose C C-Suite Rapid Action Power Brightener at Beauty Pie, £16.50 (£80 for non-members)

buy now

Beauty Pie Super Healthy Skin Gentle Foamy Facial Wash

Super Healthy Skin Gentle Foamy Facial Wash

I adore this cleanser for two reasons. The first is because this hefty bottle (390ml!) lasts for ages, and the second is because – even though it’s foaming – it doesn’t strip skin or dry it out. Instead, it’s refreshing and hydrating and over time works to refine skin.

Shop Super Healthy Skin Gentle Foamy Facial Wash at Beauty Pie, £12.50 (£40 for non-members)

buy now

beauty pie Soul Providers Energizing Body Wash

Soul Providers Energizing Body Wash

If you want every shower to transport you to the Amalfi Coast, buy this. The citrussy notes of orange, lemon and grapefruit are so bright and joy-inducing that it’ll immediately perk you up even when you didn’t know you needed perking up. 

Shop Soul Providers Energizing Body Wash at Beauty Pie, £10.50 (£30 for non-members)

buy now

beauty pie Triple Hyaluronic Acid Hydra Plump Dewy Skin Mist

Triple Hyaluronic Acid Hydra Plump Dewy Skin Mist

I’m in the minority, I know, but there’s not much I enjoy more than a post-cleanse spritz – and this mist is up there with my favourites. Packed with hyaluronic acid and ceramides, it hydrates and soothes skin.

Shop Triple Hyaluronic Acid Hydra Plump Dewy Skin Mist at Beauty Pie, £16.50 (£50 for non-members)

buy now


Images: courtesy of Beauty Pie

Sign up for our edit of what to buy, see, read and do, and receive a free mini-mag of the top 5 fashion trends you’re sure to see in 2024.

By signing up you agree to occasionally receive offers and promotions from Stylist. Newsletters may contain online ads and content funded by carefully selected partners. Don’t worry, we’ll never share or sell your data. You can opt-out at any time. For more information read Stylist’s Privacy Policy

Thank you!

You’re now subscribed to all our newsletters. You can manage your subscriptions at any time from an email or from a MyStylist account.